1) Best (Presumed) Death or Exit

Buffy in s5


2) Best Romantic Cliffhanger

Surprise! when Angel wakes up after the night with Buffy


3) Best Non-Romantic Cliffhanger

when Faith is stabbed by Buffy


4) Unforgettable Line

bored now


5) Funniest Finale

season 3?


6) Best Serious Moment in a Comedy


Buffy discovering she's going to die in Gone


7) Funniest Moment in a Drama

Anya and Andrew on the wheelchairs in s7


8) Best Shipper Moment

Tara: I am, you know.
Willow: What?
Tara: Yours.


9) Best Twist

agree with Dawn in s5


10) Twist You Saw Coming From a Mile Away

Giles in NOT the First!


11) Most GIF-able Moment

Is everyone here very stoned??


12) Best Fight (Physical or Verbal)

Buffy and Faith s3


13) Best Return by a Character (Real or Imaginary)

Faith s7



14) Top Tissue Moment (Single Tear or Sobfest)

Joyce


15) Best Use of Music

goodbye to you s6


16) Best Final Shot

Buffy smiling in the finale


17) Most Rewound Moment

the final battle


18) Best Overall Ending to an Otherwise So-So Season

s4


19) Worst Overall Ending to an Otherwise Solid Season

s2


20) Most Likely to Earn Someone an Emmy Nomination

I think the episode not the actor? Hush



21) Biggest Regret That I Didn’t Watch Live

Once More With Feeling for me too!